Soul Survivors: did someone actually get paid to make this?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Soul Survivors: did someone actually get paid to make this?
After reading so much about this alleged travesty with a lesbian Eliza Dushku as its only upside, I decided to give this a rent.
1.5 hours later I am scratching my head and saying WTF?!? I wound up having to go to moviepooper.com to find out what the ending meant, and when it confirmed my suspicions, I felt ripped off.
What's sad is movies like these are constantly getting made and called horror movies. They are horrible movies, not horror! I also noticed that the writer was also the director. Did he actually get paid to write and direct this crap? Also, the commentary where Melissa Sagemiller strokes her own ego didn't help my perception in any way whatsoever.
How do movies like this get greenlit and made? This is the kind of crap that could end careers, if there were any authentic ones that weren't brought about by nepotism I guess.
1.5 hours later I am scratching my head and saying WTF?!? I wound up having to go to moviepooper.com to find out what the ending meant, and when it confirmed my suspicions, I felt ripped off.
What's sad is movies like these are constantly getting made and called horror movies. They are horrible movies, not horror! I also noticed that the writer was also the director. Did he actually get paid to write and direct this crap? Also, the commentary where Melissa Sagemiller strokes her own ego didn't help my perception in any way whatsoever.
How do movies like this get greenlit and made? This is the kind of crap that could end careers, if there were any authentic ones that weren't brought about by nepotism I guess.
#5
DVD Talk Hero
I could be mistaken, but didn't John Carpenter's son direct this?
Could have been much better. I liked how free-roaming the movie was. Plot isn't terribly inportant to me. There was definatly too much alternative/industrial music for my taste. And a lot of the attempts to suprise and scare just fell flat.
He's no worse than Jake Scott (Ridley Scott's son).
Could have been much better. I liked how free-roaming the movie was. Plot isn't terribly inportant to me. There was definatly too much alternative/industrial music for my taste. And a lot of the attempts to suprise and scare just fell flat.
He's no worse than Jake Scott (Ridley Scott's son).
#7
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Stephen Carpenter? Doubt it's John'd son, would be in trivia part in IMDB biography.
I doubt anyone makes worse movies than Stephen Carpenter. I really would not purchase Soul Survivors for 1 cent. I would not want it for free.
I wasted 100 mins of my life on this dreadful garbage, this abomnation of horror, this shameful manifestation, this robber of life.
I doubt anyone makes worse movies than Stephen Carpenter. I really would not purchase Soul Survivors for 1 cent. I would not want it for free.
I wasted 100 mins of my life on this dreadful garbage, this abomnation of horror, this shameful manifestation, this robber of life.
#9
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: A little bit here and a little bit there.
Posts: 2,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When I saw this in the theater I was thinking that it was one of those films that was a good idea in the script phase, and then the studio got a hold of it and cut it down and it ended up being totally different from what it intended to be.
After a viewing on dvd, it's still sort of a crappy film that has decent atmosphere and a somewhat interesting premise, but whatever the true intentions of the filmmaker were lost in the final translation as the film is still muddled and the ending was
far from satisfying.
And the director is not john's son.
Stephen carpenter, the director of soul survivors, also directed one of my favorite slasher films from the 80's, The dorm that dripped blood, a film in which it still remains one of my favorite endings of a horror film.
After a viewing on dvd, it's still sort of a crappy film that has decent atmosphere and a somewhat interesting premise, but whatever the true intentions of the filmmaker were lost in the final translation as the film is still muddled and the ending was
far from satisfying.
And the director is not john's son.
Stephen carpenter, the director of soul survivors, also directed one of my favorite slasher films from the 80's, The dorm that dripped blood, a film in which it still remains one of my favorite endings of a horror film.
#11
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I cannot stress this further. This be not a movie, this be manifestation of evil.
I mean this literally: No story was present. So many events and happenings made NO sense AT ALL. Like tha ridiculous priest Jude and being sent back in time. NO SENSE.
This abomination has NO PLOT and makes NO SENSE.
It makes Goodburger look like the Godfather. Ghost Ship like The Shining.
Never before has the world seen such a godawful movie.
There's a reason for it being on the bottom 100 list. A very good reason. IT SUCKS.
Go here http://us.imdb.com/CommentsShow?0218619 and read Alexa's review, goremaster's review.
In point of fact go to the other pages and read the review. Most point out how their simply was no story present.
I mean this literally: No story was present. So many events and happenings made NO sense AT ALL. Like tha ridiculous priest Jude and being sent back in time. NO SENSE.
This abomination has NO PLOT and makes NO SENSE.
It makes Goodburger look like the Godfather. Ghost Ship like The Shining.
Never before has the world seen such a godawful movie.
There's a reason for it being on the bottom 100 list. A very good reason. IT SUCKS.
Go here http://us.imdb.com/CommentsShow?0218619 and read Alexa's review, goremaster's review.
In point of fact go to the other pages and read the review. Most point out how their simply was no story present.
#13
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: The Pacific Northwest
Posts: 3,422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
John Carpenter has only one child: a son with his former wife, actress Adrienne Barbeau. His name is Cody Carpenter, and he was born in 1983. Stephen Carpenter was old enough to have been making feature films in 1983. He is not related to John.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
I love horror, and I will happily sit through awful ones. Urban Legends: Final Cut? Bring it on! Freddy's Revenge? Sure thing! But Soul Survivors? I made it maybe halfway through. And I love Eliza. I can stand bad acting, cheap effects, recycled slasher plots, and more, but I can't take boring. It probably didn't help that I had already read reviews that said it had a strong Jacob's Ladder influence, so I figured where they were headed. But then again, I know the plot of every slasher movie and still enjoy the ride. The screenplay was dreary... about a half hour of plot stretched to feature length, and the director thought he could just fill the gaps with 'atmosphere'. Umm, not this time. And the characters... ugh. I would've even preferred the typical smartass 'hip' kids to these losers.
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Soul Survivors: did someone actually get paid to make this?
Originally posted by Dr. DVD
After reading so much about this alleged travesty with a lesbian Eliza Dushku as its only upside, I decided to give this a rent.
After reading so much about this alleged travesty with a lesbian Eliza Dushku as its only upside, I decided to give this a rent.
I thought Julia Stiles... uh... Melissa Sagemiller was pretty good in it, though.