Please select your favorite character from each matchup. For characters that are in multiple shows(Buffy & Angel, etc), consider all their performances not just the show I list.

Matchup #1

#3 George Costanza(Seinfeld)
vs
#126 Q (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

Matchup #2

#62 Dan Fielding(Night Court)
vs
#67 Bill Haverchuck(Freaks & Geeks)

Matchup #3

#30 The Doctor(Doctor Who: New Version)
vs
#99 Frank Drebin(Police Squad)

Matchup #4

#35 Dr. Perry Cox(Scrubs)
vs
#94 Fred Sanford(Sanford and Son)

Matchup #5

#14 Chandler Bing(Friends)
vs
#1115 Dr. Mark Greene(ER)

Matchup #6

#51 Barney Fife(Andy Griffith)
vs
#78 Jayne Cobb(Firefly)

Matchup #7

#19 Dale Cooper(Twin Peaks)
vs
#110 Xena(Xena Warrior Princess)

Matchup #8

#46 Dana Scully(X-Files)
vs
#83 Ralph Kramden(The Honeymooners)

Costanza
Bill
---
---
Dr. Greene
Jayne
---
---

George Costanza(Seinfeld)
Bill Haverchuck(Freaks & Geeks)
The Doctor(Doctor Who: New Version)
Fred Sanford(Sanford and Son)
Dr. Mark Greene(ER)
Jayne Cobb(Firefly)
Dale Cooper(Twin Peaks)
Dana Scully(X-Files)

I loved Seinfeld, but I gotta go with Q. I fully expect him to get trounced, but he was easily my favorite character in ST:TNG.

George...possibly the greatest sidekick of all time. Q was an occasional guest star. Not even close

Dan Fielding...Laroquette won so many emmys for Dan Fielding he started taking his name out of consideration. As good as Freaks and Geeks was it was a limited run TV show.

Dr. Mark Greene...if this was a contest between Chandler in the first four years of Friends versus Mark Greene I would probably go the other way. Unfortunately, those last six years of Friends do exist.

Barney Fife...I love Adam Baldwin, both in Firefly and now in Chuck, but Firefly was a limited run show and Barney Fife is one iconic TV characters of all time. This isn't close.

Wasn't Barney Fife played by Don Knotts?
Never mind.

George - Tough one because I love Q and I think my vote got him in the tournament, but it's Costanza.
Dan Fielding - Not even close, though I wouldnt be shocked if he lost since F&G is some kind of God-show here.
Frank Drebin - not a fan of the new Dr. Who.
Sanford - Re: Scrubs, Peter Griffin said it best.."which one was the funny guy..."
Dr Greene - Two meh choices.
Barney Fife - One of the all-time great sitcom characters, but sadly he will probably lose to someone who was on TV for 14 episodes.
Dale Cooper - I like Xena but she can't beat Agt Cooper.
Dana Scully - Damn tough matchup for Ralph. He's a legend but I'm X-Files all the way.

George - I like Q a lot, but George is one of the greatest characters ever
Dan Fielding - Prefer the show, and the character
Frank Drebin - Never could get into Dr. Who
Dr. Cox - Hard one, both were great. I like Dr. Cox a bit more
Dr. Green - The best of a bad pair
Jayne Cobb - Fairly close, ask me another day I might pick the other way
Dale Cooper - Tough, I love both these shows, but Dale Cooper is a great and unique character
Ralph Cramden - Not a fan of either show, but I like Honeymooners a little more

But he's the hero of Canton... the man they call Jayne!

Jayne got a really tough draw here. I had to go Fife, but Jayne is an excellent character given the short length of the show. I have to be honest that I understand why Firefly did not exactly take off given its "TV poison" premise, but the casting, a lot of the writing, and the acting was inspired.

Matchup #1: George Costanza(Seinfeld)

Matchup #2: Dan Fielding(Night Court)

Matchup #3: Frank Drebin(Police Squad)

Matchup #4: Fred Sanford(Sanford and Son)

Matchup #5: Dr. Mark Greene(ER) - Toughest choice

Matchup #6: Baney Fife(Andy Griffith)

Matchup #7: ABSTAIN

Matchup #8: Ralph Kramden(Honeymooners)

George Costanza
Dan Fielding
-------
Fred Sanford "this is it, the big one!"
-------
Barney Fife (don't like the show, but hate Whedon more )
Agent Dale Cooper
Ralph Kramden "to the moon, Alice!"

Frank Drebin was one of the last characters in, now it looks like he is headed to Final 64 and maybe beyond. Drebin vs Sanford should make for an interesting matchup if it happens.

Matchup #1: George Costanza (Seinfeld)
Matchup #3: Frank Drebin (Police Squad)
Matchup #4: Dr. Perry Cox (Scrubs) - Two of my favorite characters. This was a tough one.
Matchup #5: Dr. Mark Greene (ER)
Matchup #7: Xena (Xena Warrior Princess)

We have a couple of close matchups in this group. If you haven't voted already please do.

George Costanza
Bill Haverchuck
Frank Drebin
n/a
n/a
Barney Fife
Dale Cooper
Dana Scully

Matchup #1

#3 George Costanza(Seinfeld)

Matchup #2

#67 Bill Haverchuck(Freaks & Geeks)

Matchup #3

#99 Frank Drebin(Police Squad)

Matchup #4

#35 Dr. Perry Cox(Scrubs) (I love Fred Sanford though)

Matchup #5

#1115 Dr. Mark Greene(ER)

Matchup #6

#78 Jayne Cobb(Firefly)

Matchup #7

#110 Xena(Xena Warrior Princess)

Matchup #8

#46 Dana Scully(X-Files)

For those interested there is a new selection thread in the movie forum. Favorite Movie of the 90's.....

George Costanza vs. Q - Partly a pro-Q vote (de Lancie brought a great mixture of malice and humor to the role, depending on the nature of the character's appearance), but this is also an anti-George vote on my part. That character is somewhere between a narcissist and a sociopath and I simply cannot celebrate him. Plus, Jason Alexander's horrendous over-acting became a self-caricature halfway through the series and is largely responsible for me finding the series unwatchable at times.

Matchup #8: Dana Scully(X-Files) 53 43.80%
Matchup #8: Ralph Kramden(Honeymooners) 46 38.02%

I can't believe that Doctor Who is getting beat so badly by Frank Drebin.

Matchup #1: Q (Star Trek: The Next Generation)
Matchup #2: Dan Fielding(Night Court)
Matchup #3: The Doctor(Doctor Who: New Version)
Matchup #4: Dr. Perry Cox(Scrubs)
Matchup #5: Chandler Bing(Friends)
Matchup #6: Baney Fife(Andy Griffith)
Matchup #8: Ralph Kramden(Honeymooners)

I am agree with you!